Loading...

Is It a New Home or a Barn Conversion? Why the Distinction Matters

Barndominium illustration

What I cover in this video

In this clip, I point out that some people hear barndominium and imagine an existing barn converted to living space. Others mean a new house with barn-style architecture. That distinction can change the questions a county, lender or appraiser asks.

Watch the video

Starting with a barn that already exists

If you’re converting an existing barn, inventory what will stay. Will you keep the foundation, the frame, the roof or just the appearance? Have a qualified professional inspect the elements you intend to reuse. A construction estimate can change substantially once the builder knows what needs replacement and what can be retained.

Starting with a new open-concept residence

A new house can have barn-style siding, big doors and open rooms from the beginning. Show that clearly on the site plan and building drawings. For a new Calvert County residence, look at the new single-family dwelling application materials and ask which supplemental documents your location requires. Calvert County residential application checklist.

Why the difference matters for appraisal

A lender hearing “barn conversion” may picture an older structure with a different construction history from a new custom house. Give the lender that history and the finished specifications. Under Fannie Mae’s conventional guidance, comparable sales are selected on relevant characteristics, so accurate facts help identify what makes a comparison meaningful. Fannie Mae guidance on comparable sales.

How to check residential occupancy

For an existing barn, ask the permitting office what use is currently approved and what must happen before anyone can live there. For new construction, ask which final inspections and certificate are needed. Do this while evaluating the project so that the residential approval process appears in the budget and the schedule. Calvert County Resident Guide, Inspections and Permits.

Explain where construction starts

For a new build, the team can begin with the proposed foundation, framing and residential plans. With an existing barn, start by documenting what is already there and which pieces you intend to retain. A photo of the exterior alone won’t answer those questions.

Before pricing a conversion, ask the county what it needs to review the proposed residential use and ask a qualified professional to evaluate the existing structure. Give the lender an estimate that distinguishes retained work from new construction.

Read the video transcript

Transcript from the original recording, with light edits for readability.

0:00 The history of a barndominium is very simple. They used to take a barn and convert it into a living space. Hence the problem. With lending institutions and appraisers, it's actually become a stigmatized word that you're gonna have a big problem because they think you're gonna take a barn and convert it. As long as you follow the city and town and county guidelines for building a home and getting a use and occupancy permit, it shouldn't matter what you build. So you're better off calling it custom home, open concept. Cheers. Cheers.

Frequently asked questions

Official sources

See all videos in the custom home series